Monday, September 21, 2015

Albania takes in Syrian refugees, as Albanians claim EU asylum

Just a few days ago, EU's stats agency, EuroStat, claimed that only 1 out of 5 migrants arriving in European Union between April-June were actually from Syria. By their estimate, 17,770 were from Albania.

Ironically, Albania has also announced their plan to take in 75,000 Syrian refugees from the European Union.

Here's an interesting historical parallel: both Germany and Albania took in ethnic Albanians fleeing the Kosovo War in 1998-1999. 

So if there's any country in Europe well-suited to sympathize with the plight of the Syrians, it's Albania. Whether the country can effectively handle another refugee situation 16 years later remains to be seen.

Sunday, September 6, 2015

Talking Ventra with WGN's "Outside The Loop"

I recently had a great conversation with Mike Stephen of WGN's "Outside The Loop" about (you guessed it) Ventra.

You can listen here: 

As you may have picked up, I did, in fact, conduct this interview from "the middle of Bulgaria." Hence the lack of timely updates.

Rest assured, however, I will have plenty to write about once I'm back later this year. 

In the meantime, I'd be happy to answer your questions about Ventra and public-private partner ships. Just tweet/email me.

Wednesday, August 12, 2015

On Ventra, FOIA lawsuits, and demanding the truth

The Chicago Reader recently interviewed me about my FOIA lawsuit against the Chicago Transit Authority...and some of the more interesting obstacles that got in the way of it.

Since I last posted here about the results of my lawsuit (,

I uploaded all the documents for anyone to see over at DocumentCloud:

also wrote a piece for Curbed showing evidence that a consultant on the project may have sold confidential CTA info to Toronto:

There's a lot more I would say here if I weren't currently typing this on a smartphone from Europe. For now, I'll just add this:

ANY attempt to privatize a public asset anywhere (particularly if it's public transportation) deserves public attention. Public feedback. Public debate. But most importantly, it deserves the public's ability to say no to the decision-makers and question the logic and arguments from their presumed "expert" consultants.

None of this ever happened in the procurement process that led to Ventra. 

Furthermore, I hope the full scope of what I have said and written about this particular subject encourages people to demand answers from their governments - local or otherwise - when the official story just doesn't sound like the full truth.

If I can do it, you can do it, too.

Tuesday, July 7, 2015

BTW, you can still watch those "removed" Vice CeaseFire documentaries online...


Columbia Journalism Review recently published an article about Vice Media featuring and quoting me about these two stories I wrote back in 2012 for Gapers Block.

Vice has also taken flak for apparently not telling documentary subjects their participation would be used in content sponsored by a company. In one ironic example, a 2012 video about Chicago activists who stop gang fights was sponsored by a videogame whose slogan was “Revenge solves everything.” After Chicago reporter Jason Prechtel outed the story, Vice pulled the video from its website.


In contrast, when I reached out to Charles Davis, the short-lived former Vice associate editor who handled the controversial NFL boycott piece, he said he still does not know why his stories were killed. Similarly, Jason Prechtel of Chicago web magazine Gaper’s Block said Vice never fully answered his questions about the gang violence interrupters documentary that was sponsored by “Dishonored,” a violent game whose main character is seeking vengeance. At the time, Vice did not respond publicly to claims from the group, Cure Violence, that it hadn’t been told the documentary would be used to promote a videogame. “Vice’s use of a ‘communications associate’ and press spokesperson instead of letting me speak to the filmmakers involved in [the sponsored Vice website] Eye For an Eye is exactly the sort of move you’d expect from a public relations firm, rather than a news outlet that believes in transparency and accountability,” Prechtel wrote in an email to CJR.
To review, Vice created a two-part documentary about a local violence prevention/intervention group called CeaseFire. Earlier that year, the group was the subject of a critically-acclaimed documentary for PBS's Frontline called The Interrupters (which you can view here).

Vice's two-part Chicago, Interrupted series, however, had an ulterior motive: to promote a video game with the trademarked tagline "Revenge Solves Everything."

As I've previously mentioned, Chicago Mayor Rahm Emanuel's brother, Ari, has financial ties to Vice Media.

From their still-existent branded content website, Eye For An Eye:
In support of Dishonored, which shelves October 9th, VICE and Bethesda Softworks have partnered to create a unique program based entirely on the art of revenge.


Dishonored is an immersive first-person action game that casts you as a supernatural assassin driven by revenge
Technically, they were removed from Vice's webpages back then.

But after checking 5 minutes ago, you can still watch the two-part series online:

Why we can still view them today is a question I'll let you web sleuths figure out on your own.

Now if only Mayor Rahm Emanuel would explain why he's publicly slammed the title of Spike Lee's recent film project when his brother's client has made ad revenue off an 8-part web series of the same name since the year before...

Then again, looks like Spike Lee is also a client of the Mayor's brother's talent agency.

To be clear, I'm not saying the inspiration for an Entourage character should have any direct say in anyone's editorial content. 

I'm just asking for a little less hypocrisy from a man who's pledged to reduce violence throughout his time as mayor. 

Monday, July 6, 2015

6 Ventra facts I learned from my FOIA lawsuit against the CTA

A year and a week ago, I filed an Illinois Freedom Of Information Act denial lawsuit [PDF] against the Chicago Transit Authority for records related to the bidding process that led to Ventra.

On December 19, 2014, I settled with the CTA after obtaining those records.

For a variety of reasons, I've decided to disclose what I've discovered now on my own blog. And due to the fact that I have over 10,000 pages worth of PDF files, uploading and hosting it all online is a little tricky.

I'll try to make those documents available to interested media outlets later this week.

For now, here are the highlights:

1. A lot of companies were interested in building an open fare system for the first.

To built their replacement fare payment system, the CTA held a two-step Request for Proposals process.

The optional first step (and an additional Request for Comments period) allowed the CTA to assess various ideas, while Step 2 gave very specific submission criteria for would-be bidders.

During the course of the CTA's bidding process, 50 companies signed confidentiality agreements to allow them to access a CTA data portal containing financial and ridership statistics:

ACS Transport Solutions
American Express
AST Corporation
Bain Capital
Bank of America
Citi Ventures
Clever Devices
Cubic Transportation Systems
Dunbar Armored
Electronic Kowledge Interchange
Gantec Corporation
GC Services
GE Transportation Systems
GFI Genfare
Grigsby + Associates
IBI Group
Indra USA
Jeffrey A. Parker & Associates
JP Morgan Chase Bank
Korean Smart Card Co.
L.E.K. Consulting
Level 1
MESA Technology
Next Generation
Parsons Transportation Group
Quantum Crossings
Ready Credit Corporation
Resolute Consulting
Rico Computer Enterprises
Saber Software
Samsung C&T Corporation
Scheidt & Bachmann USA
Scott Balice Strategies
Sharp & Company
Svanaco, Inc DBA [doing business as], Inc.
System Development Integration (SDI)
The Revere Group
The Rise Group
Three Point Consulting
U.S. Bank
Visa USA
Walsh Construction

Many of them declined to participate in the actual Request for Proposals process, others joined forces with the companies that did.

The following companies submitted formal responses to the CTA's 38-page RFP Step 1 [PDF], released on August 24, 2009:

ACS (a Xerox subsidiary)
U.S. Bank
NTT Data
Scheidt Bachmann
System Development Integration, LLC
First Data
Blaze Mobile (sent a letter indicating that they would submit a response in Step 2)

The following later submitted responses to the CTA's "Request for Comments" about the scope of the CTA's proposed project requirements:

U.S. Bank
Scheidt Bachmann
Inside Contactless

The following submitted responses to the CTA's 527-page (later 1,248-page with subsequent addendums) Request for Proposals, Step 2, released on September 28, 2010:

Blaze Mobile
2. Cubic's Best and Final Offer of $454 million bid beat Samsung's final bid of nearly $1.46 billion.

Blaze Mobile and mPayy appear to have not participated in the final bidding. Despite records that indicate negotiations with the CTA up to the end, ACS and Accenture both declined to submit final bids.

Interestingly, ACS went on to win a $129.5 million contract to build an open fare system in Philadelphia around the same time Cubic won the CTA contract, while Accenture later won a $184 million contract in D.C.

It's worth noting that my FOIA request (and lawsuit) were partially inspired by ACS/Xerox's win in Philadelphia. From the Philadelphia Inquirer link above:
SEPTA chose ACS after a three-year-long process. 
The company offered the lowest bid, $5 million less than Cubic and $84 million lower than Scheidt & Bachmann. And it scored highest in technical reviews by SEPTA staff.
My curiosity as to why the CTA didn't disclose similar details led to what you are reading today.

3. Ventra is capable of raising CTA fares to whatever it wants, including peak/off-peak pricing and distance/zone-based pricing.

Per the CTA-Cubic final agreement, Page C-1:
The following fare options shall be supported by the OSFS [Open Standards Fare System, aka what we call Ventra] and included in the OAT [Operational Acceptance Test], unless otherwise noted below:
  • Varying fares based on route or station,
  • Specialty bus routes that have differing fare structures,
  • Express surcharges on express bus routes, a discounted fare on select peak-period shuttle routes, and a rail express surcharge on certain express train lines,
  • Varying prices by route and station including variations for not only the base fare, but transfer prices and regulations for that route or station.
  • Exclusivity for particular accounts may be required for some services, as well as;
  • Peak/Off-Peak Fares for select time periods on select days; and
  • Distance-based and Zone-based fares, to be demonstrated by the Contractor during SAT [System Acceptance Test] using temporary business rules to be mutually defined and approved during Design Review.
Page H-22:
  • Parameter settings available to CTA include, but are not limited to the following: Customer category, as defined by CTA's fare policy (e.g., regular full fare; reduced fares for seniors, disabled; employees; contractors; students); Peak and Off-peak fares; Unrestricted access; By service mode ('L', local and express buses) and individual route or combination of routes; and Times and duration of activation and deactivation in terms of hours, specifics dates, and specific time periods. 
  • CTA shall be enable to execute changes to the parameter setting for fare pricings and Fare Media purchase options through a strict change control process defined, implemented and managed by the Contractor [Cubic]

What this means is that instead of paying the same flat-rate to go (almost) anywhere along a Bus/"L" ride at anytime, the CTA can work with Cubic to raise fares significantly based on when you travel and how far you go.

Metra (which is implementing Ventra) already has distance/zone pricing. D.C. and London [PDF] do both. By comparison, here's how much it currently costs to use Ventra.

Whether the CTA goes in either/both of these directions remains to be seen.

4. The Ventra contactless card readers are/were capable of reading the ChicagoCard. 

Though the CTA explicitly asked for a system to replace it's Chicago Card, Cubic proposed and ultimately built a card reader backwards-compatible with the format.

Here are several quotes from the technical specifications submitted by Cubic in their RFP Step 2 submission.

Page 6-13:
"The reader module will be located within the turnstile cabinet, accessible to the customer through the same opening as currently used for the Chicago Card reader/writer. The reader will also be capable of reading current Chicago Cards® and Chicago Card Plus® in circulation."
Page 6-14:
The reader assembly kits consist of the following principle components: 
 Contactless Reader Module:  This unit has a similar form factor as the existing CTA contactless reader, allowing placement in the cabinet in the same location. The card reader module is also capable of processing CTA Chicago Card media already in circulation, although this feature is not required in a pure overlay solution. The location of the reader can be in the lid of the gate cabinet or (preferably) in the position currently occupied by the existing reader.  
Page 6-202:
The reader module will be located within the turnstile cabinet. The location of the reader can be in the lid of the gate cabinet or (preferably) in the position currently occupied by the existing reader. The reader will also be capable of reading current Chicago Card and Chicago Card Plus in circulation although this feature is not required in a pure overlay solution.  
The reader assembly kits consist of the following principle components:
 Contactless Reader Module:  This unit has a similar form factor as the existing CTA contactless reader, allowing placement in the cabinet in the same location, providing a boon to customers who are already familiar with presentation of contactless media in that location. The Cubic reader module is capable of processing CTA Chicago Card media already in circulation, further aiding the customer by processing all contactless media in the same location on the turnstile cabinet, removing the confusion resulting from multiple “target” with similar functionality and labeling, especially during the critical startup period. While this is TOP’s [Cubic and partners] strongly preferred solution, and we do not think it is a clear exception to the requirements of the RFP, we will indicate it as an exception, and are prepared to install the reader on the gate lid should that be required. 
5. The Ventra contactless card readers are likely based on the same technology currently used by Transport of London.

Earlier this year, TfL and Cubic won an award for their contactless open fare transit ticketing system. Part of this was due to a key component:
Central to the seamless transition was the Cubic Tri-Reader 3, developed in conjunction with TfL and the first contactless smart card device compatible with all industry standard transportation schemes and contactless payment cards.
Tri-Reader 3 is also a term that comes up throughout Cubic's submissions to the CTA.

In an email response to me, a Cubic representative explicitly denied that Ventra was based on the Tri-Reader 3 system. However, according to the technical specs of their Step 2 response:

Page 6-344:
 The reader is based on Cubic’s Tri-Reader technology and has been optimized to process contactless cards in transit environments as quickly as possible.
Page 6-233
The Open Payment Media Reader embedded in the customer-facing portion of On-Board Processor is a Cubic Tri-Reader capable of accepting contactless open payment media products, such as contactless bank-issued credit and debit media that are ISO/IEC-14443 compliant contactless smart cards for fare payment.
Page 6-234
Cubic’s Tri-Reader 3 is the contactless payment reader unit, which is comprised of an antenna board, digital processing board, and expansion board for additional memory and communications with the administrative sales device PC. Typically, the card reading range spans from 0 mm to more than 50 mm from the surface of the antenna. The ideal range is from 10 mm to 30 mm. The Tri-Reader 3 contains 4 gigabytes of Flash memory and 512 Kbytes of random access memory (RAM). The Tri-Reader 3 used in the administrative sales device is the same device that is integrated in the fare media vending devices, bus mobile validators and gates.
As I've previously written, the original Cubic Tri-Reader was designed to read the same smart card format as the Chicago Card.

6. The actual winning bid that Cubic submitted to the CTA predicted the Ventra launch problems that occurred almost two years later.

As many Chicagoans know, the actual rollout of Ventra in late 2013 was plagued with errors.

Cubic's own Best and Final Offer from November 7, 2011 contains the following quotes from its proposed launch strategy.

Page 44:
...Also we will start molding expectations about deployment. No deployment is without bumps. It is best if people are told that before implementation gets too far advanced.
After the first phase of the implementation ends...there should be another progress story offered to the press. On time, smooth sailing, bright future. 
 The first visible indication to the customers that a new system is coming will be the installation of the new bus readers. There should be another progress story related to the readers. Good visuals with the brand prominent, and how fast and cool it will be to board a bus using the new system. 
This is where a vague expectation date should be worked into the story. 'Fall' of some year, is better than a month, and way better than a day. Also take the opportunity to mold expectations. That the system will be there after we're comfortable we've worked out every bug we know about, because heaven knows there will be more.
Whether or not Cubic and the CTA successfully "molded" expectations is a question I'll leave to others.

There's one more fairly significant chain of events I've discovered in these records. I will be saving that for a separate post later this week.

After which, I will be happy to make these records available.

Thursday, July 2, 2015

Palmyra and Mes Aynak: Destroying the History of the Silk Road

As ISIS begins to destroy statues at Palmyra, Afghanistan's vast Mes Aynak archaeological site could soon be completely destroyed for a Chinese copper mine.

Both were key hubs and cultural melting pots on opposite corners of the Silk Road.

From the Guardian article about Mes Aynak:
...Its mountains and valleys were a major intellectual crossroads where the Hellenistic, Persian, Central Asian, Tibetan, Indian and Chinese worlds met and fused. Today, of course, part of what is so fascinating about the civilisation of the cities of the Silk Route is the sheer remoteness of these exotic-sounding places. Yet what most distinguished Mes Aynak in the early first millennium AD was the opposite: the fabulously wealthy and cosmopolitan nature of the society that thrived there.
At this period, Afghanistan was the epicentre of classical globalisation: midway on the trade route from Rome to China, traders came to Afghanistan from all over the world, bringing painted glass from Antioch, inlaid gold vessels from Byzantium, porphyry from Upper Egypt, ivories from South India, carpets from Persia, horses from Mongolia and Siberia, and lacquers and silk from the China coast. It was through these now-remote valleys that ideas of art, decorum, dress, religion and court culture passed backwards and forwards, east to west and back again, mixing and melding to create the most unexpected conjuctions. The slowly decaying remains of the culture that emerged from this extraordinary clash and fusion of civilisations still litters much of Afghanistan and northern Pakistan.

Thursday, June 11, 2015

It's official...American culture has reached Peak Bro.


RIP: The Bro, 1976–2015
The origins of the bro are as murky as the water in a fraternity basement wading pool, but he is believed to have been birthed in 1976, in an article by music writer Lester Bangs. More recently, the experimental 1992 film Encino Man, which boasts an impressively low 16 percent approval rating from Rotten Tomatoes, introduced the term into popular culture, where it proliferated like a bad strain of the clap on the Duke campus. It is not clear whether Pauly Shore or Brendan Fraser, the comedic duo that powered that little-loved cinematic engine, were themselves bros, or whether they remain bros to this day. Their current whereabouts are unknown, and perhaps best kept that way.
The Bro Is Still Kicking After All These Years 
A joint study of Entourage by Monmouth College and the University of Missouri-Columbia last year shows that tidings of the bro’s death may have been premature. According to the researchers, the bro’s negative characteristics are, in fact, more appealing than ever. In an era when traditional gender expectations are shifting, it seems viewers are drawn to the bro's more offensive qualities to offset their anxieties over the changing role of men in real life.
Research on sexual storytelling in male-dominated military settings has found that these groups facilitate conversations that lead friends to prioritize male-male friendships over male-female friendships, which are perceived to be "dangerously feminizing." Womanizing behaviors, on the other hand, facilitated these friendships. So Entourage is hardly to blame for a pre-existing "bros-before-hoes" culture in certain circles; but, as this study confirmed, discussion around it can't be helping, either.
Escape to Bro-Topia
Mr. Huntington built the treehouses over several months last year with the help of what he called a “bronado” of friends. He hired contractors to build the skate bowl at the same time.
Senator regrets ‘bro with no ho’ comment about colleague Lindsey Graham
Kirk was apparently referring to Graham’s recently-launched presidential bid. “I’ve been joking with Lindsey,” he is heard saying. “Did you see that? He’s going to have a rotating first lady. He’s a bro with no ho.”
A ‘bro’ asked the CIA about Osama bin Laden’s porn stash. The agency answered.
In hopes of uncovering the terrorist leader’s pornographic predilections, a determined bro named David Covucci decided to send the CIA a FOIA request on behalf of the esteemed online periodical of jockish 20-somethings known as BroBible. 
The Freedom of Information Act, enacted in 1966, essentially allows any U.S. citizen to petition the government for official information. 
“It’s a pretty powerful tool for journalists and Bros alike,” Covucci wrote, noting that he believes “us dudes” have a “right to know what the world’s most wanted” was watching.
Jason Aldean Lashes Out Against Bro-Country Label
“It bothers me because I don’t feel like it’s a compliment,” the star says of being tagged as bro-country. “To me, it’s sort of a backhanded thing that comes from a very narrow-minded listener, and I don’t know who came up with that ridiculous term.” 
Music journalist Jody Rosen actually coined the term in an article in New York magazine in 2013, talking about the huge success of Florida Georgia Line‘s “Cruise” and songs by Luke Bryan.
Bro-Country Is A Plague, And Florida Georgia Line Is Patient Zero
Bro-country embodies everything that country-music haters hate about country music: forced drawls, offensively catchy chords, a fervor for reckless self-determination, hedonism, convenient religiosity, and backward conservatism with an undercurrent of racism. 
It's also pretty much loathed by any artists who consider themselves authentic country musicians. These artists don't see bro-country as real country. 
Bro-country might sell well, but it's bad music that justifies bad behavior. Its ethos lacks any regard for responsibility, respect, or moderation. Its lyrics condone misogyny, alcoholism, overconsumption, and that's about it. Music doesn't have to be progressive. It doesn't have to be ethical or political. But it shouldn't dumb down just to double dollars. It shouldn't be simple for the sake of convenience. Listeners deserve more than that, even if they're too busy stomping their boots and choking down whiskey to realize it.

Thursday, June 4, 2015

Syrian refugees flee to Ukraine, Ukrainians flee to Western Europe

Most of the recent refugee focus has either been on Libya or the Rohingya.

Some refugee tales, however, are bitterly ironic.

One Syrian man resettled in Ukraine...only to end up a restaurant owner in Donestek.

Meanwhile, Ukrainians fleeing to Poland and Western Europe have seen rejected visa and asylum applications.

God only knows where Western Europeans will go if disaster strikes at home. Rest assured, it won't be to Hungary.

Wednesday, June 3, 2015

Russia's Nuclear Options: Nukes in Crimea, Power Plants in Asia

On one hand, Russia has threatened to station nuclear weapons in Crimea as it sees fit...scaring the fuck out of everyone in Europe already worried about Ukraine and the disturbing Russian saber-rattling across the region (more on that in a future post).

On the other hand, Russia's spreading the nuclear love elsewhere.

Russian firm Rosatom will start construction on a nuclear plant in Iran later this year...even as Iranian nuclear talks continue.

Interestingly, this construction is not barred under current agreements.

Meanwhile, Rosatom has also begun talks with India over transferring nuclear technologies across various fields. Currently, they're building a power plant in the country's Tamil Nadu province (the southern tip).

Rosatom, by the way, is Russia's state nuclear corporation. According to their website, they are also building plants in China, Belarus, Turkey, Bangladesh, and Vietnam.

Of course, they also have a nuclear weapons division.

Truly, Rosatom is a one-stop shopping destination for nuclear products. Too bad its main customer is Putin.

Tuesday, June 2, 2015

The Controversial Politicians of Instagram, From Aaron Schock to Ayatollah Khomeini

Aaron Schock resigned from the U.S. House of Representatives over two months ago when his own popular Instagram account helped prove that he misreported his travel plans as well as his use of federal funds and campaign finances. Just recently, he paid $122,000 back to the federal government.

However, this hasn't stopped other political legacies from benefiting from the popular photo/video sharing app normally associated with benign narcissistic banality.*

Famously shameless ex-Italian Prime Minister Silvio Berlusconi has one.

Ayatollah Khomeini's tribute account was recently reactivated.

Even Chechyan leader Ramzan Kadyrov -- who recently called for keeping women locked up and away from WhatsApp -- announced his two upcoming film roles from his Instagram account.

Then again, even ISIS makes cat memes.

*not linking to mine here.

Monday, June 1, 2015

France's Sustainability Double-Whammy

Recently, France required all new buildings in commercial zones to have either plants or solar panels on their roofs. This follows a new law requiring supermarkets to distribute unsold edible food so it doesn't go to waste.

Let's hope more nations follow the French example. Especially the ones still subsidizing their farms.

Tuesday, March 10, 2015

ISIS is spreading -- or is it collapsing from within?

The Libyan "expansion" of ISIS, along with the pledge of allegiance from Boko Haram, and non-stop stories of foreign fighters flocking to Syria, all paint a picture of the army thriving in spite of parallel Western and Iranian-backed efforts.

However, al-Baghdadi's own Syria/Iraq-spanning "caliphate" may be falling apart...due to the very same foreign fighters he and his supporters rely on.

According to the Washington Post, tensions between foreign and local fighters have spilled into gunfights, insurrection, and causalities.
New restrictions on travel in and out of areas controlled by the Islamic State have been imposed in recent weeks, including a prohibition on truck drivers transporting men without permission, the activist group says. Public executions, a core component of Islamic State discipline, have in recent weeks been extended to about 120 of the group’s own members, according to the ­Britain-based Syrian Observatory for Human Rights.

Some were accused of spying and one of smoking, but suspicions are widespread that most were simply fighters caught trying to flee.

Meanwhile, territorial losses in northern Syria and elsewhere in Iraq are contributing to the sense that the group that stunned the world with its triumphant sweep through Iraq and Syria last summer is now not only on the defensive but also struggling to find a coherent strategy to confront the multiple forces ranged against it.
Not to mention the undeniable desperation in recruiting deaf and mute fighters.

However, it's not just a matter of when ISIS falls. The crucial question is how will it fall?

And when we say "it", what portion of the current "sworn" ISIS fighters and support personnel will attempt to blend in with the greater Syrian/Iraqi Sunni populations? How many will remain stranded? Who will flee back through the Turkish border to their own countries in hopes of re-integration, or flee to other "hot" jihadi conflict zones?

The formal Islamic State organization may (or may not) be near its structural fault line. But it may already too late to stop the ISIS-branded black flag from living on as rallying symbol for the future.

Saturday, March 7, 2015

Goodbye, ancient Iraq. Hello, pre-Columbian Honduras.

By now, you have probably read about ISIS destroying rival mosques, ancient statues, and ruins of civilizations spanning thousands of years of human history, ranging from Assyria to Parthia. Sadly, it's another layer of tragedy atop of the (probably preventable) mass slaughter across the region.

Of course, their "pious" campaign has a size limit - they have no issue making money off idolatry if it's small and valuable enough to transport and sell on the black market.

The irony is that the Islamic State iconoclasm campaign comes the same week as the discovery of two lost ancient cities in Honduras.

One cradle of civilization gets bulldozed, another begins to awake from its jungle slumber.

Sunday, February 8, 2015

Egypt, Iraq slam an aloof Turkey over terrorist support


Egypt may sue Turkey for alleged support of Muslim Brotherhood-linked terrorism.
The judicial source said Mahmoud had claimed in his case that Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdo─čan had supported the Muslim Brotherhood movement and criticized Egypt following the ouster by the army of Islamist President Mohamed Morsi in July 2013.

The brotherhood, the movement from which Morsi hails, was declared a terrorist organization by the Egyptian government in December 2013 
Obviously, the Egyptian military has a vested interest in wiping out all traces of the Muslim Brotherhood. But these are some serious accusations:
The judicial source added that the lawyer filing the case also claimed that Turkey was the main source of arms entering Egypt that ended up in the hands of terrorists.
“Turkey [has adopted] hostile stances against Egypt after it became a haven for Muslim Brotherhood leaders who face criminal charges in Egypt,” the judicial source quoted Mahmoud as saying in his lawsuit.
Meanwhile, another majority Arabic Muslim state has accused Turkey of supporting terrorism.
“They (Turkish authorities) say that the border is too broad and they cannot control it. I believe that they can control it. It is in the interest of our partners to stop the flow of terrorists to Iraq,” Prime Minister Haider al-Abadi said at the 51st Munich Security Conference in Germany on Saturday.

Turkey has come under international criticism for allowing thousands of foreign terrorists to join Takfiri groups such as ISIL, which has captured some parts of Iraq and Syria.

Interpol has warned that foreign terrorists are increasingly going to Turkey through booking tickets on cruise ships to join Takfiri groups in Syria and Iraq.
In Turkey's partial defense, porous border control is easier said than done.

After all, the U.S. can hardly contain the flow of cartel-distributed drugs from across the Mexican border that fuels violence in major cities like Chicago.
The drug trade in Chicago has helped fuel pervasive gang violence that has resulted in a quickly rising homicide rate. Chicago ended 2014 with 425 murders, and this year the city had seen 30 slayings by the end of January.
Then again, countries like Saudi Arabia and Qatar have explicitly funded various groups in Syria and Iraq, using Turkey as a base of operations.
Ankara has been quite public with its denunciation of Assad even as it denies any involvement in shuffling weapons across the border to Syrian rebels. It claims its territory is not being used to do so. And yet, as TIME reported in June, a secretive group operates something like a command center in Istanbul, directing the distribution of vital military supplies believed to be provided by Saudi Arabia and Qatar and transported with the help of Turkish intelligence to the Syrian border and then to the rebels. Further reporting has revealed more details of the operation, the politics and favoritism that undermine the task of creating a unified rebel force out of the wide array of groups trying to topple the Assad regime.
Currently, Erdogan seems more concerned with rooting out all (real or imagined) signs of a Fethullah Gulen insurrection (whose own Chicago ties I've written about here) than the perception that the country is clashing with its previous allies and becoming a hub of the region's problems:
That is why I think Turkey is increasingly becoming an important part of the problems and coming close to becoming the center of crises in the Middle East – not because Turkey under the AKP is challenging the Western powers, as its supporters claim. Instead, it is because Turkey’s rulers have ultimately turned the country into a volatile and unpredictable political actor for both its friends and foes internationally and increasingly autocratic domestically.
Whatever course Erdogan takes his country in, it'll follow his vision of a powerful, influential, independent Turkey -- global ramifications and public opinion be damned.

Like What You Read? Share It.

Share |